Choosing between large format and traditional tiles? This detailed comparison helps Toronto homeowners make informed decisions.
Size Definitions
**Traditional Tiles**: 12x12 inches or smaller **Large Format Tiles**: 15x15 inches to 24x48 inches **Slabs**: 5x5 feet to 5x10 feet
Cost Comparison in Toronto Market
#Material Costs - Traditional: $3-$15 per square foot - Large Format: $8-$25 per square foot - Slabs: $20-$60 per square foot
#Installation Costs - Traditional: $8-$12 per square foot - Large Format: $12-$20 per square foot - Slabs: $18-$30 per square foot
#Why Large Format Costs More - Specialized equipment required - Higher skill level needed - More expensive adhesives - Longer installation time - Greater breakage risk
Benefits Comparison
#Large Format Advantages ✓ Fewer grout lines (less cleaning) ✓ More contemporary aesthetic ✓ Makes rooms appear larger ✓ Faster coverage of large areas ✓ Dramatic, seamless look ✓ Higher perceived value
#Traditional Tile Advantages ✓ Lower material cost ✓ Easier to work around obstacles ✓ Better for uneven surfaces ✓ More DIY-friendly ✓ Wider contractor availability ✓ Better for small spaces with many cuts
Installation Challenges
#Large Format Complexity - Requires laser-level substrates - Needs lippage control systems - Demands specialized cutting tools - Heavy (safety concerns) - Difficult in tight spaces - Limited ability to hide imperfections
#Traditional Tile Easier Because - Forgiving on slightly uneven surfaces - Smaller cuts easier to make - Lighter and safer to handle - More contractors comfortable with installation
Best Applications by Size
#Choose Large Format For: - Open-concept living areas - Master bathroom walls - Kitchen backsplashes - Modern/contemporary designs - Homes with minimalist aesthetic - High-traffic commercial spaces
#Choose Traditional For: - Shower floors (better slope) - Small bathrooms - Complex layouts with many obstacles - Budget-conscious projects - Traditional/classic designs - Backsplash with intricate patterns
Maintenance Differences
#Large Format - Less grout to clean and seal - Easier daily maintenance - Individual tile replacement more challenging
#Traditional - More grout maintenance required - Annual sealing recommended - Easier to replace damaged tiles
Toronto Climate Considerations
Both handle Toronto's temperature extremes well when properly installed. Key factors: - Proper waterproofing critical for both - Thermal expansion considerations - Heated floor compatibility (both work)
Resale Value Impact
In Toronto's competitive market: - Large format adds perceived luxury - Increases value in modern homes - Traditional tiles fine for classic homes - Quality of installation matters more than size
Making Your Decision
Choose **Large Format** if you: - Want modern, contemporary look - Have budget for premium materials - Value low-maintenance - Have large, open spaces - Plan to use professional installer
Choose **Traditional** if you: - Prefer classic aesthetic - Have budget constraints - Have small or complex spaces - Many cuts required around fixtures - Want DIY option
Prime Tiling's Recommendation
We install both daily across Toronto and the GTA. The "right" choice depends on your specific project. We offer free consultations to assess your space and recommend the best option.
Serving Toronto, Mississauga, Brampton, Vaughan, Oakville, Markham, Richmond Hill, and all GTA communities.
Contact Prime Tiling for expert advice on your tiling project.
